Apart from Logan and Josh, she dated Nicholas Carpenter from 2006 to 2008, Frank Pugliese from 2001 to 2004 and Robert Downey Jr. Despite her broken past, it looks like she was not completely broken but only bent.
Logan could have married Marisa and become her future darling husband.
It's harder to be taken seriously when you're younger, doing that but I've also come to a point of being able to handle the reaction to it - that probably would have been more ...
When it comes to Marisa Tomei and men, it seems that she has a variant taste. Let's talk in detail about their love affairs and married life, just stay with us.
Marisa, who came to prominence as a supporting cast member on The Cosby Show spinoff A Different World in 1987, still looked effortlessly cool and fresh-faced when she started the morning healthily at a juice bar with the How I Met Your Mother star in West Hollywood on Sunday.
Josh, 39, also dressed down in a hoodie, navy trainers and grey corduroys, looked engrossed in conversation as he and Marisa ordered a melange of blended fruit to take away before the pair ambled along the sun-dappled streets of West Hollywood yesterday.